WHO IS ISOLATED IN THE MIDDLE EAST? RAPHAEL ISRAELI
Who is isolated in the Middle East? by Raphael Israeli
http://www.icjs-online.org/index.php?article=3359
Leon Panetta, the American Secretary of Defense has just stated on his way to the Middle East, that Israel has never been so isolated in the region and that the current changes in the area are not to its advantage and therefore, based on American unshakable support for its security and defense, it could afford to take more risks for peace. This is the kind of statement made by the English press, which decries Europe’s isolation during storms in the Channel at Britain’s temporary separation from the Continent.
The two countries that Panetta advises Israel to make up with are Turkey and Egypt, and he also means the negotiations with Palestinians when he counsels to “take risks for peace”. He knows that it was the government of Turkey, which is headed by a thug who constantly incites his people against Israel with lies and venom, that has launched the break with its close ally when he, in Davos, assaulted the Israeli President, Shimon Peres, who could not have been more accommodating towards him and the Palestinians. The flotilla provocation of 2010, and the resulting rejection by Turkey of the Palmer Report which concluded that Israel did not violate international waters when it imposed its legitimate embargo against Gaza, show that no matter what Israel does, Erdogan would always find fault with her.
Similarly with Egypt – Israel has kept a low profile during these months of uncertainty which have characterized the Arab Spring, that is turning into a cold winter. It was the Egyptian gas supply to Israel that was interrupted by sabotage on 5 occasions, the Israeli Embassy that was attacked as the security forces were watching by, the arms smuggling into Gaza that continued to run undisturbed by Egypt’s security guards, the turning of the Sinai into an active base for al-Qa’ida and its Hamas ally against Israel, and it is the Egyptian presidential candidates and other politician running for office who all declare the need and intention to revise, alter or improve the terms of the peace treaty with Israel. Israel did nothing to cause either the internal chaos in Cairo or to put in doubt its support for the 30-year old peace accord, which it considers a strategic asset.
The rest of the troubles in the Middle East were not caused by Israel either, and if partly attributable to any foreign meddling, it is the US which has to repent for her major mistakes in the area, which have influenced the unfolding events much more deeply and radically than what Israel could have done. The US indeed failed to react when its long and established military presence in Turkey, in the times of the civilian governments of Ozal and Ciller, was erased by the Erdogan majority parliament and government, exactly when the US needed to channel its troops via Turkey to allow a second front in the war against Saddam. It failed miserably in checking the nuclearization of Iran; it rescued Assad out of his isolation, just to see his troops pelting the US Ambassador with tomatoes, and it watched helplessly the pro-Hariri coalition ousted by the Hizbullah thugs of Lebanon, who receive their instructions from Teheran and Damascus. As a consequence, American stature is diminished in the Middle East and the world, and even among its western allies, and in the UN it finds itself less awed than even before. Who is then increasingly isolated?
The point is that instead of preaching to others about their isolation, blaming them for it, and prompting them to take risks to rescue themselves from it, Panetta ought to comprehend that Israel cannot afford to behave like America, who took all the risks of “engaging” Iran, the Muslim Brothers and Syria, of abandoning a long-term ally like Mubarak, and of showering the Palestinians, the Afghanis, the Pakistanis with aid, and saw all those gestures of largess backfiring on her, translated on the ground into more effusive anti-Americanism, more vitriol and hatred and American flag-burning than ever. If instead, the US created a new alliance with its western and western-minded friends to set up a second line of staunch defense of Western and Judeo-Christian values, to counter the mounting Islamic wave, which the Arab Spring will only aggravate. with the committed backing of Iran, Turkey and Pakistan, then a new world order, better and more stable, might finally emerge out of the present chaos.
The author is a professor of Islam and the Middle East at Hebrew University in Jerusalem.
Comments are closed.
