RUTHFULLY YOURS

http://pjmedia.com/ronradosh/2010/08/20/a-message-to-conservatives-is-islam-really-our-enemy/?print=1

RON RADOSH, WHO HAS, ON OCCASION WRITTEN SOME GOOD COLUMNS, HAS TAKEN OVER FRONTPAGE FOR HIS ASSAULT ON DIANA WEST AND HER BOOK “AMERICAN BETRAYAL”…TODAY, RADOSH RESPONDS WITH ANOTHER DIATRIBE AND IS ABETTED BY JEFFREY HERF WHO SLAMS WEST WITH AN OUTRAGEOUSLY FALSE IMPLICATION ABOUT HER BOOK. IT IS SORT OF UNPRECEDENTED THAT A REPUTABLE SITE WILL TAKE DOWN A REVIEW IT PUBLISHED AND SUPPLANT IT WITH JEREMIADS AGAINST THE AUTHOR DIANA WEST. TO ADD INSULT TO INJURY, THE EDITOR DAVID HOROWITZ ADDED HIS REMARKS IN AN OP ED DEFENDING THE “HISTORIAN” (HUH?) RADOSH WHO IS HIS FRIEND FOR SIXTY YEARS. AH FRIENDSHIP. WHAT LOYALTY. BUT HERE IS A DEMONSTRATION OF “HISTORIAN” RON RADOSH AND HIS UNDERSTANDING OF ISLAM. HE SCOLDS ALL THE CONSERVATIVES WHO ARE MORE PRESCIENT AND KNOWLEDGEABLE ABOUT ISLAM THAN HE COULD EVER BE…..ROGER KIMBALL, ANDY McCARTHY, DAVID SWINDLE, GEERT WILDERS, INCLUDING A PIN PRICK TO HIS FRIEND OF SIXTY YEARS DAVID HOROWITZ, AND ADMITS HE DID NOT READ BAT YE’OR BUT SUSPECTS MANY WOULD TAKE EXCEPTION TO HER AS WELL. HE DOES HOWEVER CONSIDER JEFFREY GOLDBERG “ONE OF THE TOP JOURNALISTS OF OUR TIME” EVEN THOUGH GOLDBERG CALLED THE GROUND ZERO MOSQUE IMAM RAUF A “TRUE MODERATE”. AND BY THE WAY GOLDBERG STATED IN JANUARY 2013 ON “SETTLEMENTS” THAT “IRAN POSES A SHORT TERM THREAT TO ISRAEL’S SURVIVAL: ISRAEL’S OWN BEHAVIOR POSES A LONG TERM ONE.”

HIS OTHER GURU IS STEPHEN “SULEYMAN” BIN KOSOVO SCHWARTZ A FORMER HARDENED BOLSHEVIK WHO CONVERTED TO ISLAM AND IS NOW A PROMINENT SUPPORTER OF THE LATE ALIJA IZETBEGOVIC WHO IN HIS YOUTH WAS A RECRUITER FOR THE BOSNIAN MOSLEM BRIGADES ORGANIZED BY THE NAZIS, AND AS AN ADULT WAS A PROMOTER OF A GLOBAL CALIPHATE AND RECRUITED AL QAEDA INTO THE BALKANS DURING THE BOSNIAN CIVIL WAR.…RSK

Introduction and Note to Readers:

Warning: This blog is very lengthy, and has taken me a few days to write and to compile the material discussed herein. You may want to print it. I originally planned to run the different parts on consecutive days. But much of the material is time-bound and events may occur in these coming days that answer some of the tentative questions I raise.

My intention is to set off an honest and real debate about the issues I raise. I am frankly distressed about the growing volatile and rancorous choruses on the Right that seem to insist that there is only one position to take on the nature of Islam. By giving full links to the various sides, you can read through all of them and reach your own conclusions.

But the subject is too serious to act on partial and misleading information, or on the blogs coming particularly from one strident side. So please- read and think!

Part I: Who is Our Enemy?

First: Diana West is my friend. I admire her, respect her and trust her research.

I read her book “American Betrayal” carefully. I came to her book with a serious difference with her over Senator Joseph McCarthy who was Senator while I was experiencing a political growing up at Bronx High School of Science where supporting the candidacy of General Eisenhower was heresy, to say nothing about the “sainthood and martyrdom” of the Rosenbergs.

Like George Orwell, McCarthy’s name altered the dictionary…and “McCarthyism” became synonymous with punishment and harassment of dissent…..I went along with this until I read “Witness” by Whittaker Chambers; until I realized that the Communist hunter James Jesus Angleton (a C.I.A. counterintelligence agent and one of the men who helped found the Mossad in 1951) was right about a Russian/Communist mole in the C.I.A. even though he was called a “crackpot conspiracist”; until the revelations that J.Robert Oppenheimer, the head of the Manhattan Project may have been a Soviet agent (the Alsop brothers hysterically compared the investigation of Oppenheimer to the Dreyfus affair); until I read Diana’s book. Maybe….just maybe…Joseph McCarthy, not the most attractive or likeable messenger was on to something really big. “American Betrayal” is persuasive, informative,meticulously researched and documented and convincing.

Now, many may disagree.David “Spengler” Goldman, a friend whom I like and respect agrees with Ron Radosh. So does a dear friend of mine who has courageously exposed the radical agenda of the climateers and so called environmentalists, so does Jamie Glazov, another person whom I like and respect, so do many others, and Frontpage had every right to publish Radosh’s nasty review.

But, and this is the serious butt of the scandal…Frontpage should not have removed Mark Tapson’s good review and then as a conciliatory crumb offered Diana the chance to rebut Radosh. I don’t blame her for refusing and all the squirming and offensive name calling and apologetics at the site don’t excuse their craven decision to remove Mark Tapson’s review which they had accepted and posted.

In good time and in a venue of her choosing Diana west will reply, I can’t wait to read and post it.

Here is Diana’s response:

I have not had time to respond to the massive hit piece against my book American Betrayal posted today at Frontpage.com.

I will.

I would like to point out in brief, however, the simple, lowdown mendacity of the “Editors’ note” — that would be editors David Horowitz, Jamie Glazov, perhaps others — that tops 7,000 words of misrepresenting, twisting, and omitting by Ronald Radosh passed off as a “review.”

(This is the Radosh m.o., by the way, as briliiantly exposed in 2008 by M. Stanton Evans.)

Here it is:

Editors’ note: Frontpage offered Diana West equal space to reply to Professor Radosh’s points below. She refused.

To say that this misrepresents the truth is one of those understatements of the year.

First of all, Frontpage doesn’t inform their readers that they are actually looking at Frontpage American Betrayal Review #2.

Frontpage posted an earlier review — Review #1. It was positive. They removed it — purged it. (It is archived at Ruthfully Yours.) This is unheard of. Quite commonly, controversial books rack up more than one review, more than one opinion. The commissars of Frontpage don’t permit “incorrect” opinion, however, so the positive review of my book was removed from the website. On my incredulous inquiry of Glazov, he proceeded to explain in emails to me that the reviewer, Mark Tapson, “lacks the expertise” to review the book, and later, that the problem was the review’s “inaccuracy.” I asked what was innaccurate in the review and received no reply.

http://frontpagemag.com/2013/dgreenfield/the-amnestyville-horror/print/ Wake up an amnesty supporter in the middle of a muggy Washington D.C. night and the first words out of his mouth will be, “It’s not amnesty.” And he’s right. It’s not. The 1986 amnesty or the Immigration Reform and Control Act, which neither reformed nor controlled immigration, took in some 3 million illegal […]

http://www.nationalreview.com/node/355270/print The Affordable Care Act — a.k.a. Obamacare — is off to a very rocky start, and according to the law’s biggest defenders, the blame falls squarely at the feet of Republicans. It’s an odd claim. Republicans did not write the law. They did not support the law. And they are not in charge of […]

http://www.nationalreview.com/node/355291/print It happened again. Sensitive intelligence has been leaked to the news media to boost President Obama politically and to distract from the various scandals plaguing his administration. The New York Times and McClatchy reported earlier this week that the Obama administration’s decision to close 22 embassies was occasioned by intelligence gathered from intercepted electronic […]

http://www.familysecuritymatters.org/publications/detail/politically-incorrect-posters-and-islam?f=puball On July 9, 2013, Munich police confiscated a poster used at a city demonstration opposing the proposed Center for Islam in Europe-Munich (Zentrum für Islam in Europa-München, or ZIE-M) due to preliminary hate speech suspicions.  The Munich confiscation raises questions about the ability to state unvarnished facts about Islam, however displeasing. The conservative German […]

http://www.familysecuritymatters.org/publications/detail/cbo-underestimates-real-costs-of-delay-of-obamacare The Congressional Budget Office last week released its calculation of the impact of the Obama administration’s decision to delay ObamaCare’s employer mandate for one year. Intentionally or not, the CBO’s $12 billion estimate is flawed, understating by a wide margin the cost to taxpayers. On July 3, the Obama administration said that it will […]

http://www.familysecuritymatters.org/publications/detail/perhaps-its-not-her-man-huma-stands-by Huma Abedin — wife of candidate for New York City mayor and disgraced former U.S. Rep. Anthony Weiner, D-N.Y. — is confounding political analysts. Why, after her husband recently admitted on the campaign trail he had continued his sexting exploits subsequent to resigning from office in 2011, would she continue to stand by her […]

http://pjmedia.com/blog/obama-tells-marines-al-qaeda-is-near-defeat-decimated/?print=1 Just days after issuing a sweeping terror alert that broadly warned Americans against global travel and temporarily closing embassies across the Middle East, President Obama returned to pressing his longtime narrative that al-Qaeda is on the run. Obama told Marines at Camp Pendleton this afternoon that he was there to mark the war in […]

http://pjmedia.com/claudiarosett/the-uns-millennium-development-flop/?singlepage=true At the United Nations, America’s new ambassador, Samantha Power, reported for duty on Monday. In remarks [1] just before presenting her credentials, Power listed some of the top items on her UN to-do list, including working together “to alleviate global poverty.” Let’s hope Power takes a look at a new study of UN development […]