Columnist Peter Beinart warned this week that “unless they change course, [U.S. President] Donald Trump and [Israeli Prime Minister] Benjamin Netanyahu are going to get Jews killed.”
Writing in The Forward about Palestinian threats of violence in response to Israel’s authorization of 2,500 new housing units in existing settlements, and discussions in Washington over a possible move of the American Embassy in Israel from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, Beinart hastily added that, “of course,” neither leader wants Jewish blood to flow.
Nor, he said, was he “trying to detract from the primary moral responsibility of those Palestinians who detonate bombs or shoot guns or stab with knives. Palestinian terrorism is inexcusable. It always has been. It always will be.”
And then he got to the crux of the piece: If Netanyahu ignores the assessments of Israeli security experts — as well as the saber-rattling of a member of the Jordanian government and chief Palestinian peace negotiator Saeb Erekat — he will be just as guilty of the terrorism that is sure to ensue as those who perpetrated it.
To give greater weight to his argument, Beinart first presented the positions of those who favor Israeli settlement construction and the relocation of the U.S. Embassy, and then refuted their logic.
One such position was that “Israel should never be cowed by the prospect of Palestinian violence.”
”To do so,” he said, “would be to imply that Israel deserves some of the blame for that violence, which is like blaming a woman who is raped for wearing a short skirt.”
Indeed.
But here is where Beinart returned his own volley with a mighty whack. Unlike rape, he wrote, which “is purely a product of male pathology, Palestinian violence … is a pathological response to a genuine grievance.” Aha.
In other words, Israel really is at fault for getting raped — whether it wears dresses or pants; curtsies or bows; begs or pleads; or fights back. It is to blame for the plight of the Palestinians. In fact, if not for the “violence” of Jewish oppression, they would be teaching their children to sing “Kumbaya” and plant flowers, instead of raising them to become martyrs for Allah.
Yes, according to Beinart, “Snuffing out their hopes of ever tasting the basic freedoms that David Friedman and Jared Kushner take for granted is violence.” Kudos for so deftly killing two Jews — the incoming U.S. ambassador to Israel, and Trump’s son-in-law/adviser — with one stone.