http://dianawest.net/Home/tabid/36/EntryId/3775/The-Fear-in-Bob-Woodwards-Soul.aspx
In 2012, Politico, of all outlets, listed six big disputed reports from Bob Woodward.
(1) The potted plant to signal “Deep Throat”
(2) CIA Director William Casey’s deathbed scene
(3) Tenet’s WMD “slam dunk” quote
(4) Justice Brennan voting against conscience to curry favor
(5) Reagan recovery scene
(6) John Belushi portrayal in “Wired”
Catch up on them here.
What made these examples of disputed Woodward reporting newsworthy was the stunning 2012 revelation in New York Magazine, as Politico put it, that “legendary Washington Post editor Ben Bradlee once expressed `fear in my soul’ that Bob Woodward had embellished elements of his reporting in the Watergate scandal.”
Leaving readers mouths agape, Politico moves on to its own list.
This does not begin to do the Bradlee story justice. In “The Red Flag in the Flowerpot: Four decades after Watergate, there’s something that still nags at Ben Bradlee about Deep Throat,” Jeff Himmelman, author of the Bradlee biography, Yours in Truth (ironic), not only reports on finding this comment in Bradlee’s papers — which Bradlee did not publish in his own memoirs — but, more amazingly, the very strange effect it had on Woodward at the prospect of publication.