TARGETED KILLINGS AND DOUBLE STANDARDS: JUSTUS REID WEINER….SEE NOTE PLEASE
http://jcpa.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/tk-5jun12.pdf
JUSTUS WEINER “OUTED” EDWARD SAID’S LIES ABOUT HAVING BEEN BORN IN JERUSALEM, DISCLOSING THAT SAID WAS, IN FACT, BORN IN EGYPT….THE EVIDENCE QUOTED SAID HIMSELF AND COULD NOT BE DENIED….SAID IS STILL THE MUSE OF COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY AND THE MIDDLE EAST STUDIES ASSOCIATION (MESA NOSTRA) BUT THE LIE DID MUCH TO DEBUNK HIM…..RSK
Nils Melzer, Legal Advisor for the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), defines targeted killing (TK) as “the use of lethal force attributable to a subject of international law with the intent, premeditation, and deliberation to kill individually selected persons who are not in the physical custody of those targeting them.”
-
On the one hand, there is a TK policy which has been conducted in almost full compliance with HRW’s stated test, executed with remarkable transparency, and put under intense local and international public scrutiny (including judicial review). Most remarkably, the policy has achieved unprecedented levels of intelligence accuracy. This TK policy was implemented with precision targeting and virtually no mistakes as regards the location of the terrorist – and with less than one civilian fatality average per TK.
- On the other hand, there is a TK policy which in many cases did not comply with HRW’s stated test, conducted behind the cloak of systemic and deliberate opacity, with virtually no public scrutiny. Due to faulty or compromised intelligence, this policy resulted in many incidents which ought to have raised red flags regarding the core principles of distinction and proportionality – and with a ratio of more than ten civilian fatalities per TK.
The writer, an international human rights lawyer, is a Scholar in Residence at the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs.
Comments are closed.